1929 vs 2025: Andrew Ross Sorkin on Crashes, Bubbles & Lessons Learned
All-In with Chamath, Jason, Sacks & Friedberg Podcast Recap
Published:
Guests: Andrew Ross Sorkin
What Happened
Andrew Ross Sorkin delves into the 1929 stock market crash, citing a lack of character-driven narratives as his motivation for writing about the era. He notes the shift in American attitudes towards borrowing, starting in 1919 when General Motors began offering credit for car purchases, a concept that was previously considered a moral sin. This credit culture quickly spread to other sectors, with Sears Roebuck and National City Bank following suit.
The unchecked speculation in the 1920s led to a 48% increase in the stock market in 1928, with rampant insider trading and manipulation due to the absence of the SEC. Banks and corporations were heavily invested in the stock market, often using depositor funds. Despite being aware of the speculative bubble, the Federal Reserve hesitated to raise interest rates, further fueling the frenzy.
Sorkin draws parallels between the 1929 crash and modern financial markets, highlighting differences in leverage and regulation. He emphasizes the role of key figures like Charlie Mitchell of National City Bank, who advocated for practices that led to the crash, and Carter Glass, whose opposition led to the Glass-Steagall Act. This act was pivotal in separating commercial and investment banking and establishing the FDIC.
The current economic environment shares similarities with the 1920s, particularly in the leverage seen in real estate and private credit markets. Sorkin argues that speculation is essential for innovation but warns against letting it spiral out of control. He also touches on the accredited investor rule, originating from the 1930s, designed to protect less wealthy individuals from risky investments.
AI's impact on the economy is discussed, noting its contribution of 100 to 200 basis points to GDP. While AI is propping up the economy, it also incites psychological insecurity among business leaders. Sorkin mentions that excluding the AI boom, the economic landscape would look significantly different.
Historical context is provided, with unemployment in the U.S. reaching 25% in 1932. The New Deal and World War II were crucial in turning around GDP during the Great Depression. Sorkin suggests the need for a new social compact in America, given the inflated costs from government spending on education, housing, and healthcare.
Key Insights
- Andrew Ross Sorkin identifies a major cultural shift in the 1920s when borrowing money transitioned from being a moral sin to a widespread practice, beginning with General Motors offering credit for car purchases.
- The absence of regulatory bodies like the SEC in the 1920s allowed rampant insider trading and market manipulation, contributing to the stock market boom and subsequent crash.
- AI is currently adding 100 to 200 basis points to the GDP, and its absence would have left the economic landscape significantly different, emphasizing its role as a crucial economic driver.
- The Glass-Steagall Act, influenced by Carter Glass's opposition to risky banking practices, fundamentally restructured the financial industry by separating commercial and investment banking and establishing the FDIC.
View all All-In with Chamath, Jason, Sacks & Friedberg recaps