Shock Lawsuit Against "The Tell" Author, Kouri Richins Bombshells, and Nancy Guthrie Investigation Mess, with MK True Crime Hosts | Ep. 1271 - The Megyn Kelly Show Recap

Podcast: The Megyn Kelly Show

Published: 2026-03-12

Duration: 1 hr 59 min

Guests: Mark Garagos, Matt Murphy, Ashley Merchant

Summary

This episode dives into major controversies, including a lawsuit alleging stolen trauma in the memoir 'The Tell,' shocking revelations in the Kouri Richins murder trial, and the ongoing investigation into Nancy Guthrie's disappearance.

What Happened

The episode kicks off with an in-depth discussion of the lawsuit against Amy Griffin, author of 'The Tell,' who allegedly stole another woman's childhood sexual assault story and claimed it as her own. Griffin reportedly used memories recovered during MDMA therapy, but the lawsuit alleges that these details were in fact stolen from a former classmate, Claudia, who has come forward with extensive allegations. The panel critiques Griffin’s defenses and explores the potential fallout for Griffin's media supporters, including Oprah and Reese Witherspoon, who promoted the book without skepticism.

Next, the focus shifts to the Kouri Richins trial, where the Utah mother is accused of murdering her husband with a fentanyl-laced Moscow mule. The prosecution has presented a damning letter, dubbed the 'Walk the Dog' letter, allegedly showing Richins attempting to fabricate evidence to frame her husband as a drug user. The trial also includes testimony from a housekeeper who claims Richins purchased fentanyl explicitly for this purpose. Questions remain about witness credibility and the circumstantial evidence.

The disappearance of Nancy Guthrie is revisited, with commentators criticizing Sheriff Chris Nanos for his handling of the case. The episode highlights how media coverage and law enforcement leaks have muddied the investigation. A previously undiscovered 2013 Today Show clip showing the interior of Guthrie's bedroom raises questions about how credible ransom claims could have been fabricated using widely available footage.

The Guthrie family's potential legal action against journalist Ashley Banfield is also discussed. Banfield had reported that Savannah Guthrie's brother-in-law, Tommaso Sione, was a prime suspect in the case, based on a law enforcement source. The panel explores the likelihood of a defamation suit and concludes it would be unsuccessful due to Banfield's careful phrasing and source protection.

Finally, the episode covers a chilling IVF clinic mix-up in Florida, where a couple discovered the baby they carried and gave birth to was not biologically theirs. Legal experts discuss the clinic's liability and the emotional toll on families. The issues of genetic testing and determining custody of the baby are explored, along with the logistical nightmare of identifying the biological parents.

Throughout the episode, the guests provide sharp legal analysis and insights into the implications of these high-profile cases, underscoring the broader societal issues they reveal.

Key Insights

• Amy Griffin’s book 'The Tell' faces a lawsuit claiming she stole a former classmate’s childhood sexual assault story, allegedly uncovered through MDMA therapy. The case raises questions about the ethics of memory recovery and the responsibility of media giants like Oprah and Reese Witherspoon, who promoted the book without verifying its authenticity.
• Kouri Richins, accused of killing her husband with a fentanyl-laced Moscow mule, left a trail including a 'Walk the Dog' letter prosecutors claim shows her plotting to frame him as a drug user. A housekeeper’s testimony that Richins bought fentanyl for this purpose exposes the risks of circumstantial evidence when credibility is in question.
• A 2013 Today Show clip showing Nancy Guthrie’s bedroom may have undermined ransom claims in her disappearance, as it gave the public access to personal details. This blurs the line between investigative journalism and potential tampering with an active case, complicating law enforcement’s efforts.
• A Florida IVF clinic mistakenly implanted a couple with another family’s embryo, leading to the birth of a baby not biologically theirs. The legal and emotional fallout highlights the lack of safeguards in genetic testing and the chaos of determining custody when such errors happen.

Key Questions Answered

What is the lawsuit against Amy Griffin about on The Megyn Kelly Show?

Amy Griffin is accused of stealing a former classmate's childhood sexual assault story and claiming it as her own in her memoir 'The Tell.' The lawsuit alleges she used unethical methods, including hiring private investigators, to gather details.

What is the evidence against Kouri Richins in her husband's murder trial?

Key evidence includes testimony from a housekeeper who claims Richins purchased fentanyl, a letter allegedly showing her fabricating evidence, and her financial motives tied to her struggling house-flipping business.

How could the IVF mix-up in Florida be resolved legally?

The case hinges on genetic testing to identify the biological parents of the baby born to Tiffany Score and Steve Mills. The clinic's liability is likely significant due to the devastating emotional and logistical consequences.