'The Nice Guys' With Bill Simmons, Chris Ryan, and Rob Mahoney - The Rewatchables Recap

Podcast: The Rewatchables

Published: 2026-03-24T01:00:00.000Z

Duration: 5373

Guests: Rob Mahoney

What Happened

Ryan Gosling's comedic performance in 'The Nice Guys' is lauded as one of his best, with Bill Simmons and Chris Ryan noting his exceptional timing and willingness to take risks. The movie's 1970s setting is celebrated for its authentic depiction of the era's style and cultural elements, including the gas shortage and killer bees, which were genuine concerns at the time.

The chemistry between Ryan Gosling and Russell Crowe is identified as a crucial factor for the film's charm. Rob Mahoney points out that their dynamic is reminiscent of classic buddy comedies, yet the film's sleazier tone sets it apart from predecessors like 'Midnight Run'. This unusual blend of comedy and grime contributes to the movie's cult status.

Shane Black's directorial style is credited for the film's gripping scenes, such as the opening shot of Los Angeles and the car crash. The hosts appreciate Black's ability to balance action with humor, a skill he honed in previous works like 'Lethal Weapon' and 'Kiss Kiss Bang Bang'.

Despite a modest box office performance, earning $62.8 million against a $50 million budget, 'The Nice Guys' has gained popularity through frequent cable and streaming appearances. Its complex plot is more enjoyable on repeat viewings, as noted by the hosts, who compare it to other films that found success post-theatrical release, such as 'Anchorman'.

The film's critique of major corporations is highlighted as a theme that resonates with contemporary audiences, with the plot involving Detroit automakers as villains. This layer adds depth to the narrative, making it more than just a typical action-comedy.

The potential for a sequel is discussed, with ideas to set it in the mid-80s or another location like Mexico. Ryan Gosling's current fame could help drive a sequel, following the successful model of other films that gained traction after their initial release. The absence of a typical love interest in the film is noted by the hosts as a refreshing change from genre norms.

Key Insights

• Ryan Gosling's performance in 'The Nice Guys' is seen as one of his best comedic roles, thanks to his adept timing and risk-taking, which differentiates him from other actors in similar genres.
• The film's authentic 1970s setting, including real historical concerns like the gas shortage, enhances its appeal and illustrates the era's cultural nuances effectively.
• Shane Black's direction is crucial to the film's success, particularly in how he balances action and humor, with standout scenes such as the opening helicopter shot and the chaotic car crash.
• Although 'The Nice Guys' had a modest box office showing, its complex plot and dynamic performances have led to a growing cult following, aided by frequent airings on cable and streaming platforms.